UK time is: 18:49:07
Vital Login
Social Login

Choose your club

Other Sites

Network Navigation

Vital Partners

'If It's Football, It's Vital'

Its all about money

The two current ongoing transfers the club is struggling to finalise are both, in different ways, all about money.

In the case of Adebeyor its about a club being held to ransom, in the case of Modric it may be about exchange rates and the Spanish economy. I said all last season that whatever happened to Ade there was no way he was going to lose money on the deal.

Now, it appears, having agreed a deal with Spurs Ade is demanding City's 5m transfer fee to make up the shortfall in earnings. The problem for City is there is no way out, 5m is 28 weeks wages, keep Ade another year and it costs them even more. Indeed keep him one more week, making 6 weeks of the transfer window, and it will have already cost them a million.

Even if another club made a better offer it wouldn't necessarily help, Ade doesn't have to agree a move. If I was cynical I might think Levy was quite happy with the current situation, its hard to see how City can win and every week Ade remains on their books is a week off our wage bill.

I have no sympathy for City, they didn't have to offer the player such an obscene amount of money. I do wish it would give some of our supporters pause for thought though before they moan about the club not giving players huge pay rises, wishful thinking I know.

The Modric sage is confusing but one thing to note is that sometimes stories quote the fee in Pounds, sometimes in Euros. This doesn't matter as long as exchange rates are stable, only they're not, the Euro has dropped about 10% against the Pound over the past 12 months. That would still not be a problem in a cash up front deal, you know the exchange rate on the day. Problem is that Real want stage payments, which immediately means one side or the other has a currency risk.

If the deal is in sterling then Real run the risk of the pound strengthening against the euro, if the deal is in euros then we run the risk of getting less than we thought. From Levy's behaviour I get the impression the deal would be in Euros. There is a further risk, what if Spain dropped out of the Euro altogether? It may seem a remote prospect but given the state of the Spanish economy (25% unemployment and a collapsing banking sector) it could happen.

If you were owed money by a Spanish club in a currency that either they no longer belonged too or no longer existed would you ever get paid?

To me it makes perfect sense for Levy to want to get paid for Modric up front, debts stretching out over several years are not a good idea in the present economic climate.

Written by jod




Use your social login to comment on front page articles. Login using you Facebook, Twitter, Google or LinkedIn accounts and have your say!



Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

The journalist

Writer: Jod Mail feedback, articles or suggestions

Date:Monday August 6 2012

Time: 8:54AM

Your Comments

Agreed
maccaspur
I'm one that believes the Chairman Will do the right thing for the club.
maccaspur
Very god points!
Tactically Challenge
Dear mr levy.... Buy Damiao! If we miss out on him, I'm going to be so *****ed off
Danny_cypher
sell now 30 million then we can move on with profit
spurs50yrs
Good article jod i think you have summarised both situations very well. Personally I'm beginning to think that we should drop Adebeyor, it's not as if he is poor is it yet he hasn't been prepared to reach a compromise with his current employers in order to be able to participate in our pre season training and tour. Just says to me that, as with most players now, it's all about greed and suggests he is not bothered whether he joins us or not.
TQ2Spurs
Danny_cypher has Damiao ever said he wants to play in the Europa League and not in the CL? In his shoes where would YOU go?
maccaspur
Ade will come in, eventually. City are being held to ransom and that's simply too bad for them. They're going to have to cough up the cash and let him go and then just accept the fact that if you want to pay through the roof in order to poach the best talent from other clubs, AND THEN not play those players it will come back and bite you on the bum.

As for Modric...the situation has sort of changed in my eyes in light of Redknapp's recent comments. If he was in fact promised the chance to join Real this summer then I think he should be allowed to do that. Surely a deal can be struck where the reported 30m +8m in payments deal is paid in pounds. This wont be like last summer where the club were able to say "give us one more year" and Luka got his head down and saw in out.
KierzoSBC
A very interesting read jod and valid points indeed...
Mix26
The Adebayor numbers don't add up to me though. From City's point of view they are on the hook for 18m of salary going to him and then he walks after 2 years. This way they pay him 5m, save 18m in salaries and get 5m transfer fee from us. So it would cost them 8m but save them 10m.

For Spurs we would probably also pay a signing on fee in the region of 3m, would pay him 8m over 2 years and pay City 5m transfer fee. That is 16m over 2 years and if we put him on a 4 year contract it will cost us 24m.

For Adebayor he gets 8m in his pocket, another 8m wages and a guarantee of another 8m for 2 more years taking him to 32 years of age. That would imply that everyone is happy. However, clearly it isn't as they are still quibbling over the detail. It's difficult to knock Adebayor though as City were stupid in the first place to guarantee him that money. He is protecting what is contracted to him.
muttley
First paragraph makes no sense. It should just be cost them 5m but get 5m from us which means they save 18m.
muttley
Ade will come but Damiao would send notice of intent to other teams and Spurs supporters. Keeper position we can live with. Modric/Mountinho is final piece to resolve - I think Modric makes us tick and would not want anyone else if he was !00% Spurs committed - sadly I think that has run its course
sandrotheman
In previous articles I have stated we should take the money and run. The quicker we get Modric out, the quicker we can get new players in. This is going to affect our pre season and the stability of the team. Anything over 30m is a huge profit on a player that does not want to play for us. Get him out and get a striker in.
vicspur
Damiao has said that he will only leave if a decent offer for him and his club came in?! If levy would take a chance, then we wouldn't keep missing out on players... Look at falcao, we could've bought him for 25 mil, he's worth about 40 now! Sandro said about Damiao before and we just dragged our heels
Danny_cypher
A thoughtful article with an interesting analysis of problems that are not usually laid out for consideration in this way. Thank you, Jod.
Airwave
wat the annoying thing is we have plenty of money from sales in the last 2yrs PLENTY SO WHY ARE WE not looking for a bloody striker and we have been looking at Damiao for 2bloody yrs defoe not good enough and Kane to inexperienced and seems to quick for him Redcrapps comments are rubbish if you remember correctly redcrapp was in the papers bleating about that we must sell him not to Madrid to the chavs!!! last season Daniel Levy stance has always been the same 40mill so what is different apart from 19m We end up half way if LEVY doesnt reverse redcrapps decisions to sell all our bloody forewards and the fans will turn very quickly! because some them thought redcrapp was the bee all to end all
spur1950
Great article. My question is, if we know that Luka will never play for Spurs again and that we are just digging our heals for those few extra coppers, why not buy his replacement now? Yes Real will know that we are then desperate to sell, but it simply means that buying Moutinho or whoever will be slightly cheaper so either way it works out the same plus we then get Moutinho now rather than standard Spurs on last day of the window with no pre season prep etc.
mattgazza
The stalling can only work in spurs interest if they have a plan, to play not relying on Modric or Ade- at the moment, we don't have like for like players. Ade needs to be concluded soon, and same with Modric. The only saving grace is Bale maybe used as a striker/winger with either VDV or Siggurdson just behind. There is no excuse not to add to the forward line, because this shouldn't weaken our position, but its clear we need to wait for Modders deal, before a goalie & quality midfied player is bought. Sell Modric for the 30m and be done with this nonsense.
T-spur5
Good article JOD except the one thing not mentioned anywhere is "football", that's what we do, what we are, a football club. The Adebyor deal either needs sorting in the next 48-72 hours, or kicked into the long grass, and we need to look elsewhere. The Modric deal needs sorting NOW, especially if, as alleged, we require the Modric money to finance any other tranfers. In case it has escaped the attentions of our global financial whizz kid Mr. Levy, while he is deeply involved in his game of Monopoly, we are going to Newcatle a week on Saturday, with a side that is in no way competitive, we have 1 striker in Defoe who is hardly good enough, plus GDS and two kids available to play up front. We have pratted about trying to get Ade in, and followed our usual "Forsyth Saga" method of selling Modric, whilst all the time the clock is ticking, players are signing elsewhere, and we are nowhere nearer to solving problems that have existed for at least 2 seasons, and have been exaserbated by the sale of Crouch and Pavyluchenco, and the end of Adebayor's loan period. Only an idiot would argue that we can compete without quality up front, so rather than worry about the Euro crisis, something that even Levy as clever as he allegedly is, cannot effect, and waiting for City and Adebayor to stop playing silly buggers, would he please, please get his arse into gear and go out and get at least 1, ideally 2 strikers in. Yes it will cost a few quid, something that goes against the Lewis/Levy grain, but in the real football world that's how it is, if they don't like the heat I wish to Christ they would get out of the kitchen, and sell the club to someone with some ambition, and determination to succeed, things that we have lacked right from th beginning o the ENIC tenure.
Frank
As to the exchange rate problem, RM and Spurs could work out a deal that is paid half in pounds sterling and half in euros over some specified time. If the pound increases or decreases in value, one half of the value of the payments rises and the other half falls. In the end, the fluctuations all come out in the wash. I worked for a while getting paid half in American currency and half in Brazilian currency, and it matters not to me at that time whether the dollar rose or fell in relation to the Brazilian real. Not that difficult for a decent accountant to figure out the details of such a deal.
Total knobhead
Fair points Jod, though I don't buy the whole exchange rate thing. Parties do not have to be restricted by the actual rate, they can set and agree their own internal rate - yes it means someone may loose out, but it also means the other party is guaranteed an acceptable minimum, basically it has a built in floor that regardless of the RoE the bottom line never falls lower. Many companies that do global business fix exchange rates with partners, especially in times of volatility in the markets
Cape Town Spurs
Interesting article jod and nice to hear things from a business perspective and not an emotional one which I think we're all guilty of at times. I'm confident Ade will join us and as you and many others mention who can blame him for standing strong when he already has a contract. I do think that if football was his priority he would have a somewhat different approach though. As for the exchange rate issue with Modders, I work in finance and there are mechanisms available to counter any flexibility in rate changes over time. Essentially you place a bet on movement in each direction so that any potential losses can be countered. Hedge Funds use them extensively hence the term "Hedging your bets". Still an important factor though and well pointed out.
phynix_uk
@ Frank, I have a lot of respect for Levy and the way he runs the club and for one do not hope ENIC sell any time soon as I believe he does have a vision and it is edging nearer in a stable way. I'm not going to be the idiot that argues about the striker situation though. I've said myself in numerous posts, we sold Berbatov, Pav, Keane, Crouch, have seen the end of loan deals for Saha & Adebayor and brought in, well, ABSOLUTELY NO-ONE. It does boggle the mind and is starting to boil the blood!
Cape Town Spurs
Good article jod, I think that's the most objective piece ive seen on the Adebayor issue, better than the predictable rubbish the media produce. Adebayor is doing what every player, agent and club have done to City since the Arabs came in, try to get as much out of them financially as possible.
Guyver
NO MONEY, NO HONEY !!!!!
spu 4 life
TQSpure - said the same last week.

Ade is not bothered about playing for us he just wants to maintain his current salary or be compensated if he has to take lower wages.

Rather we pull the rug from under his feet and get a younger more enthusiastic player that WANTS to play for us - what is it with players we are a top four club challenging a new regime and great facilities.

The articel makes good points and Levy I believe will do what is best for the club and I respect him for that and I agree we need to resepct what Levy does with regards keeping us afloat in this mad world of football and awful uncertain economy. Fans on here sometimes are niave - when your running a business no matter what your feelings for the club are you cannot allow your emotions to rule.

How many people on here have allowed their emotions to rule usually when 'love' is involved and they have lost money or their decisions have cost them dearly probably everyone - Levy cannot do that he has to keep his accountant business hat on regardless of his feelings or love for the club.

As for all this media gossip and spouting off about who said this and who said that I take it with a pinch of salt. Like Levy is going to make any promises to anyone that could be detrimental to our club what do people think - that he is stupid - come on fams give him vredit he didn't get where he is now by making false promises and neither do I believe any player would agree on a 'word of mouth' or 'hand shake' promise - their agents wouldn't let them and although some footballers are known to have little between their ears I doubt they have NOTHING between their ears they wouldn't accept a promise in their world of football unless it was clearly set out on paper.

When will people realsie that 99.9% of all this talk and accusations is paper talk or bitterness or revenge.

Just let the management and board get on with things and apply patience - we are going in the right direction.
thfan
It's not clear to me that Adebayor is being a dick to Spurs, but is trying to get more money out of City. He might have them at a disadvantage. They give him more money or he stays there and collects his salary without having to play. If they are desperate to offload him, they might need to buy him off. But is there any indication that he's trying to extort anything from Spurs? Tell me if you know of it.
Total knobhead
TK, there is no evidence of Ade trying to extort anything from us, so as usual some will just fill the forum with conjecture. Let's jump on everyone involved, Ade is a helm, Levy is tight, AVB should be sacked this week, Harry was the messiah who's achievements put him in the pantheon of greatest ever managers, and Gold, Sullivan and Brady should be coerced on board to lead us into a bold new era.
Crissybwoy
lol chrissybwoy. lol
Total knobhead
TK.......I'm not sure if anyone has suggested that Ade is being a dick to Spurs as such, certainly not me, but I do question his commitment to playing for our great club because he has been unwilling to reach an agreement/compromise with Citeh so that he could train and have a pre season with us, if the deal does eventually go through late in the transfer window he will not be match fit and we will already be a couple of weeks into the season. It's not as if the blokes hard up is it, he needs to accept that he was on artificially high wages at Citeh and no other club are going to pay the same.
TQ2Spurs
I'm waiting for the headline 'exchange rate scuppers player move shocker'
lordjohnny
You are getting closer to the "gambe" zone when you'll either have players available on the cheap or you won't have decent talent to buy, the way you going about your transfer business. Sell Modric for the 30Mil + add on's and secure a replacement earlier
@Mq
Oh, and have faith in AVB about talent identification (Oscar) and buying (Mata) because he knows what he's doing in that department
@Mq
 

Have Your Say

Log in...
with your social network     OR     with your Vital account

Recent Spurs Articles

Tottenham Hotspur vs. Asteras Tripolis. (Thursday October 23 2014)

Are We There Yet? (Wednesday October 22 2014)

Manchester City vs. Tottenham Hotspur (Friday October 17 2014)

Veljković loan confirmed! (Thursday October 16 2014)

Managing Transfers (Thursday October 16 2014)

Fountain of Youth (Tuesday October 14 2014)

So whats wrong with Lewis? (Monday October 13 2014)

We're off to the City! (Friday October 10 2014)

Footballing Enigmas (Wednesday October 8 2014)

Yesterdays Men. (Tuesday October 7 2014)

Archived Spurs Articles

List All Vital Spurs Articles
Have your say
Click here to suggest an article
Click here to suggest a poll

Vital Members League (view all)

1. Real Deal 187
2. 80deg16minW 185
3. spurdon 185
4. Spursex 176
5. MAN ON! 166
6. Spurfect11 162
7. Slurms McKenzie 140
8. USAFSPURS 119
9. BigSpursFan 115
10. griddo 110

League Results (view all)

Latest Results
Man City 4 - 1 Spurs
Spurs 1 - 0 Southampton
Arsenal 1 - 1 Spurs
Spurs 0 - 1 WBA
Sunderland 2 - 2 Spurs
Spurs 0 - 3 Liverpool

League Table (view table)

Team P W D L GD Pts
6. Man Utd 8 3 3 2 3 12
7. Arsenal 8 2 5 1 2 11
8. Swansea 8 3 2 3 1 11
9. Spurs 8 3 2 3 -1 11
10. Stoke 8 3 2 3 -1 11
11. Hull City 8 2 4 2 0 10
12. Aston Villa 8 3 1 4 -8 10

Breaking League News

Sam's City Press Conference!
West Ham : 23/10/2014 17:22:00
United Happy Talk!
Man Utd : 23/10/2014 17:16:00
Mixed Injury News Ahead Of Palace
WBA : 23/10/2014 17:08:00
Duo Called Up By Brazil
Chelsea : 23/10/2014 17:06:00
Bitter and Twisted?
Man Utd : 23/10/2014 16:53:00

Current Site Poll (view all polls)

Your prediction for Spurs v Asteras?
Suggested By:  Vital Spurs
Spurs Win! 73%
Draw? 9%
Greek Tragedy! 18%