UK time is: 13:56:23
Vital Login
Social Login

Choose your club

Other Sites

Network Navigation

Vital Partners

'If It's Football, It's Vital'

What's the difference?

As the debate rumbles on about whether or not to play a 4-4-2 system or stick with 4-5-1 (or whatever variation you want to conjure up, one question has been haunting me throughout - What is the difference in modern day football?

The 4-4-2 formation has almost become a taboo in football. Why on earth play such an archaic formation which isn't even thought of amongst the elite clubs in the world and is scoffed at by anyone with any kind of tactical nous. While it's true that a standard looking 4-4-2 isn't regularly seen in modern day football, I'm wondering whether most are kidding themselves that there's a difference between playing two strikers compared to playing someone 'just off the front man'.

A 4-5-1 by definition should make the midfield more compact when defending and will allow support to a front man when in possession - but really is that the case? In the last couple of seasons we've tried and tested a 4-5-1 with van der Vaart, Sigurdsson and Dempsey all having a stab and I have to question what any of them have brought to the table in terms of being a midfielder. Answer? Very little.

I then have to question why we would play someone 'off the lone striker' who isn't as comfortable scoring a hatful of goals as, say, a striker, but also isn't really (either) capable nor willing to put the work in defensively to see the benefit. Against Maribor and yes, I will use them as an example, Defoe and Adebayor looked as promising a partnership as any other combination we've tested. We simply didn't look any different. When one went forward, the other tracked back. Adebayor especially looked very capable at dropping deep and spreading the play, working channels etc and his unselfish and mature display that night led to a Defoe hat-trick.

I feel, of course, there are times and places to play a midfield trio, in games where we're scrapping for a point or hoping to nick all three, but it seems like we're playing with one striker just because it's more fashionable, rather than more effective. Obviously I'm willing as ever to debate and take other opinions on board, but my personal opinion is that playing one up front, while it can work, simply isn't this season and no player we've had to my knowledge has played the suspiciously ambiguous 'erm, not quite midfield, not quite striker' role effectively enough.

Written by Bernio Villas-Spuras




Use your social login to comment on front page articles. Login using you Facebook, Twitter, Google or LinkedIn accounts and have your say!



Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

The journalist

Writer: Bernio Villas-Spuras Mail feedback, articles or suggestions

Date:Tuesday November 13 2012

Time: 9:00AM

 

Have Your Say

Log in...
with your social network     OR     with your Vital account

Recent Spurs Articles

Young guns - 2015-16 beckons! (Sunday April 26 2015)

A Look At The Spurs Injury Table (Friday April 24 2015)

Southampton Vs Tottenham Hotspur (Friday April 24 2015)

Pricing Strategy (Thursday April 23 2015)

Walker Out: Who In? (Wednesday April 22 2015)

If Hugo, I go... (Wednesday April 22 2015)

Lennon or Mirallas? (Wednesday April 22 2015)

My Way Or The High (Road)! (Tuesday April 21 2015)

Lessons from Wembley (Monday April 20 2015)

Alli Wins League Crown! (Monday April 20 2015)

Archived Spurs Articles

List All Vital Spurs Articles
Have your say
Click here to suggest an article
Click here to suggest a poll
ScoopDragon Premier League Network Sites

Vital Members League (view all)

1. Highgatespur 460
2. Spursex 400
3. Real Deal 253
4. 80deg16minW 172
5. spursgirl_4_life 166
6. MAN ON! 129
7. Spurfect11 122
8. dogeatdog 109
9. Taricco the yid 109
10. Big Chiv 98

League Results (view all)

Latest Results
Southampton 2 - 2 Spurs
Newcastle 1 - 3 Spurs
Spurs 0 - 1 Aston Villa
Burnley 0 - 0 Spurs
Spurs 4 - 3 Leicester City
Man Utd 3 - 0 Spurs

League Table (view table)

Team P W D L GD Pts
3. Arsenal 32 20 6 6 31 66
4. Man Utd 33 19 8 6 28 65
5. Liverpool 33 17 7 9 11 58
6. Spurs 34 17 7 10 6 58
7. Southampton 34 17 6 11 21 57
8. Swansea 34 14 8 12 -3 50
9. Stoke 34 13 8 13 -3 47

Breaking League News

The Ped Report...City 3-2 Aston Villa
Man City : 26/04/2015 13:41:01
Advocaat Left Feeling Indifferent.
Sunderland : 26/04/2015 12:52:01
Lukaku and Osman return to face United
Everton : 26/04/2015 12:40:00
All Hail Tim Sherwood - The Messiah
Aston Villa : 26/04/2015 12:38:00
Boss Looking For Two Wins
Sunderland : 26/04/2015 12:22:00

Current Site Poll (view all polls)

Spurs MOTM against Southampton?
Suggested By:  Vital Spurs
Lloris 10%
Dier 25%
Fazio 0%
Vertonghen 8%
Davies 0%
Bentaleb 16%
Mason 0%
Lamela 0%
Eriksen 0%
Chadli 0%
Kane 0%
Chiriches 0%
Dembele 0%
Soldado 41%