Writer: OxfordSpur 
Date:Monday November 19 2012
Time: 10:00AM
It seems that the game today has forgotten how to defend and our superstar ladened teams are all style and little substance!
Now for me defending isn't all about a back four, as any team not in possession need to have players from top to bottom that can will the ball back. Perhaps the game has moved on from the hard-men of my youth, but is that a good thing? As a kid, the likes of Ron 'Chopper' Harris, Norman 'Bite yer legs' Hunter and even out own legends like Graham Roberts, loved a tackle and battle, but how many players are there in almost any teams defensive line that could be considered to be a hard-man or someone that would put his body on the line to save his team? dare I suggest that the number os very small and shrinking every season as teams strive for technical excellence and the game gets ever more sanitised.
Perhaps when we look at Tottenham's back four on Sunday, we could easily make the excuses that we had two or three of our stronger players missing. Kaboul, BAE and maybe now we can even put Steven Caulker in that category, at least to bolster our argument, but we still started with three full internationals and a player who was an U-21 regular. Add to that we played with two defensive midfielders to protect things and we still manage to concede five! Have players become wimps? Have the rules taken away the ability to tackle or has the obsession with free-flowing attacking football made the art of defending extinct and the role of the stopper or defensive rock and position consigned to history?
To be honest, I still can't decide whether to applaud AVB for his tactical changes at half time or to be questioning why we fell apart so easily in the first half. was that due to defensive fragility or indecision? Should we have capitulated so easily at the loss of Adebayor? As a fan, I have to question why our two banks of four were breached so easily and so often. Perhaps some would have felt it a defensive change, but would we have been 3-1 down if we had simply brought on Tom Carroll or Gylfi Sigurdsson for Aaron Lennon just after the sending off? Retaining two wide men is great for a counter attack, but you have to have the ball to do that and perhaps with only Defoe in attack, bolstering the central areas would have served us better than making a radical change at HT to a system that was all about chasing a game, which was a little after the horse had bolted.
As fans, we can perhaps rightly look at William Gallas, or any one of our defenders for blame and perhaps if we were able to pick our best XI or certainly kept an XI on the field for play for more than seventeen minutes, we would all be signing the praises of AVB and his players, but instead we conceded another five at the Emirates and for once we can't blame our manager for being overly cautious. That last train of thought did bring me to thinking that AVB has buckled slightly to fan pressure, in looking to play the Tottenham way and also reverting to the now fans favoured 4-4-2? Was Saturday a game where AVB showed he was learning lessons or capitulating to fan pressure?
This season was always going to be one where we perhaps had to take one or two steps back to hopefully make a long term leap forward, and for many of us, we can't truly judge our new manager until he has several key players fit and also been able to bring in others that clearly seem to fit into his blueprint of football. I seem to recall writing something similar early in the reign of Juande Ramos, but I sincerely hope that both Andre Villas-Boas is made of sterner stuff and also that Daniel levy has learned many lessons from past experience...
Fixtures for next season! (Wednesday June 19 2013)
With friends like Madrid … (Tuesday June 18 2013)
Reality cheque!! (Tuesday June 18 2013)
Utter Nonsense (Monday June 17 2013)
Our midfield… (Monday June 17 2013)
WHO, WHERE and WHY?. (Sunday June 16 2013)
Adam Smith wants chance at Spurs or PL loan. (Saturday June 15 2013)
Musings of Nonsensical proportions. (Friday June 14 2013)
Wilshere to Man Utd (Friday June 14 2013)
What is an offer we can't refuse? (Thursday June 13 2013)
| 1. | 80deg16minW | 232 |
| 2. | Spursex | 216 |
| 3. | Real Deal | 157 |
| 4. | spurdon | 127 |
| 5. | coopsieyid | 120 |
| 6. | ScottDaYid | 85 |
| 7. | Spurfect11 | 74 |
| 8. | Kinygerbils | 69 |
| 9. | redbloodcell | 67 |
| 10. | ahx00 | 60 |
| Latest Results |
| Team | P | W | D | L | GD | Pts |
| 12. Newcastle | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| 13. Norwich | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| 14. Southampton | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| 15. Spurs | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| 16. Stoke | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| 17. Sunderland | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| 18. Swansea | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| Saints Starlet Linked To Cherries Loan Move
» Southampton : 19/06/2013 13:18:00
|
| Mata, Mourinho and Barcelona - There`s More!
» Chelsea : 19/06/2013 13:05:00
|
| Staying or Going?
» Chelsea : 19/06/2013 13:04:00
|
| Midfielder Link
» Chelsea : 19/06/2013 13:02:00
|
| The Answer is NO!
» Chelsea : 19/06/2013 13:01:00
|
| Cavani Talk Lingers On!
» Chelsea : 19/06/2013 13:00:00
|
| Romeu, Romeu, wherefore art thou Romeu?
» Chelsea : 19/06/2013 12:58:00
|
Everyone seems to lack patience, fans, media pundits, reporters etc., these days. FFS, how long would Fergie have lasted at Manure today? Not the 5 years he got, thats for sure!
Midfield, Bale has been poor in doing any defending, his ego is growing all the time, he is not the player he was going forward and he hardly defends, he spends a lot of time roaming. I do not mind losing his defending responsibilities if he runs up that wing as he used to do but he doesn't becoming very lazy.
Lennon is quite good at defending especially for a small guy. There are times he is easily beaten but he has a lot of defending to do with Walker being positionally pance and woefiul, so credit to Lennon in that department.
Sandro does well as he has very little help in the middle, so credit to him.
Hudd well hopeless at defending, easily beaten and immobile most of the time.
Player behind the striker, Siggy or Dempsey, well I have seen Siggy try and defend but he is not that good and hasn't impressed me with his work rate in defending or attacking and Dempsey, absolutely useless, lazy, ineffective and disinterested, noway will he take responsibility to defend.
So back four. Vertonghen class act but can be beaten when on the left side, he is a CB but he also needs a good partner to compliment his game. A player that is class and will get better and better with time and right partnership - well done to him.
Gallas - oh dear a CB that did well for us when needed but clearly out of his depth. Too slow, gets out of position, and has a weak heading ability, how many times has he either missed heading the ball or when he has head the ball it hasn't been strong enough. Time to go, no way is he good enough and a top four player.
Walker as mentioned, woeful. Got his reputation on speed, even last year it was clear to see his positioning and defending was average. Now PL players have sussed his speed game his weaknesses are being highlighted even more. We need a better RB and Walker needs to up his game and get his head down if he is to become a regular PL RB.
BAE for all is mishaps is a very good player and has been missed. Naughton is not good enough yet, will he be, well he hasn't shown me enough to say yes, but it is a learnong curve for him but he is not good enough for us his defending is weak.
Last;y GK. Friedal, he doesn;t know how to defend, and yes I believ GK need to be able to defend as well in the modern game. Lloris I think does know how to defend just hope he knows how to be a GK in the PL. If he does then we will have a very good GK but until we see more of him we don;t know enough.
So at the moment we have imo Vertonghen, Sandro and Lennon all doing their defending duties with Caulker who is a very good defender still finding his feet and Lloris potentially. Now how can you expect us to be in that top four when it is clear to me that too many players are not pulling their weight.
When you scrutinise what players are contributing as a team such as defending you start to see there is a problem running through the team.
We could do the opposite and ask do we attack as a team?
There's 22 men on the pitch and only 1 ball, the thing that scores the goal. It seems the modern game is about what an individual can do when they have the ball as oppossed to what they can do when they don't - which is most of the time! The first thing you have to do is get the bloody thing back so tackling is something you want all of the team to be able to do not just one or two 'ball winners'....so we need to perfect the pressing and shape of the team as a whole and we'll stop conceeding so many....
The main problem as I see it is the lack of backing in the market from the board.
Before anyone says "Ahh but ENIC have invested £45 million on a new training centre", take a second and ask yourselves how much the old site in Chigwell is worth to a property developer. Levy doesn't have a degree in Land Economy for nothing.
There is blame for AVB in my opinion though in some player selection. Gallas, but for a couple of games, has been horrid. The ManU game was the perfect example. OK we won. He was hobbled most of the game (hamstring he has been holding most games). Showed himself to be the class warrior we all know him to be. BUT..... he also showed himself to be slow and unable to keep the line. He and Walker were a collander (sieve would have slowed the flow a little). I would rather have Dawson in there. His long balls are no worse than all of Gallas' errant passes and dare I say, long balls. And his reading of the line is no worase than Gallas who consistently plays guys onside when Walker isn't. Dawson is not better than a 27 year old Gallas, but he is miles better than a 35 year old Gallas who loses players in the defensive zone, is at full stretch on everything and thus makes errors like heading the ball right back in to the middle. It's just too much. Gallas was awful at the start of last season, came in to his own and then petered out. He was done then. He should not be ahead of Dawson in this squad. Lloris played well. Friedel would not have made any saves on the goals conceded and there were two saves lloris made that Friedel never does. It's time for Gallas and Friedel to sit. COYS
Thought Carroll was very assured under the circumstances and absolutely no sense in dropping Defoe for the foreseeable future. Just because you don't like the guy, it'd hurt the team you support more if he were to be dropped.
I know and I agree we have not been playing poorly considering the resources available to AVB. Also, AVB seems to be making reasonable decisions on game days. However, bottom line is we are losing games and that is disappointing, especially when all our direct challengers are not firing on all cylinders. :-(
Some on here say we have a similar team to last year and therefore should perform as well. No, we do not have the same team. We lost 2 of our best players in Modric and VDV. I don't care that VDV cannot play 90 minutes but like Raging said, VDV is a winner and leader plus when he comes on things happen.
I am not sure what SPURS management is trying to achieve for us in the next few years. We seem to be taken a step forward and then we take a step back. Are we really saving up for the stadium? Have we genuinely replaced the loss of Robbie Keane and Berbatov from 3 years + ago? Could Levy have done better in the last 2 years? I think the answer is a resounding yes! We have some good players in our books at present. If Levy does not get his act together soon, players like Bale, Dembele, Vertonghen and Lloris are not going to want to hang around for too long.
Finally, can we all stop comparing HR and AVB. HR had 2 years to have a good go at it and gave us a taste of CL. Thanks. However, in the final 12 months, he basically stuffed up in more ways than one and he had to go. COYS and To Dare is to DO